Where does transfer pricing really come from? From tax rate differences between countries, loopholes in the legal system, or from the internal profit optimization strategy of the enterprise? Understanding the nature and causes of transfer pricing helps enterprises proactively comply with regulations, while supporting tax authorities to improve control efficiency, towards a more transparent and fair business environment. Let's find out with MAN - Master Accountant Network through the article below.
Causes of transfer pricing behavior
Reason transfer pricing It is not accidental but comes from many different factors, related to economics, law, corporate governance and profit optimization motives. Understanding each group of transfer pricing causes helps businesses prevent risks and at the same time supports tax authorities to improve control efficiency. In particular, economic causes play a key role, because these factors are often the direct motivation for businesses to seek to adjust prices. affiliate transactions to optimize profits.
Economic reasons
One of the most common reasons for transfer pricing is economic. Businesses often seek to optimize global profits and reduce tax obligations in high-tax markets. Tax differences between countries or regions are a key driver of internal transaction price adjustments.
For example: A multinational corporation headquartered in Vietnam and a subsidiary in Singapore, where corporate income tax rates are lower, may adjust internal sales prices to shift profits to Singapore, thereby reducing the total tax payable in Vietnam. This is a common economic strategy, but if left unchecked, it could become illegal transfer pricing.
In addition, the pressure to maximize profits and market competition also makes it easy for businesses to adjust selling or purchasing prices between related parties to achieve expected profit targets. Economic factors such as production costs, fluctuations in raw material prices, and exchange rates can also indirectly encourage businesses to carry out transfer pricing to protect net profits.
Understanding the economic causes not only helps tax authorities develop effective control measures, but also helps businesses self-assess risks and proactively prepare transfer pricing documents, comply with the law, and reduce the risk of being prosecuted or fined.
Internal management reasons
In addition to economic factors, the cause of transfer pricing also comes from internal management, one of the important reasons for the appearance of transfer pricing behavior. In multinational corporations, the business structure is complex, dispersed in many countries and many subsidiaries, leading to difficulties in controlling and separating the value of related transactions.
Pressure on KPIs and internal profits is also a driving factor. When management sets high profit targets, business units may adjust internal selling prices to meet KPIs, leading to transfer pricing risks. Lack of strict internal monitoring and control processes also facilitate this behavior.
Legal and policy reasons
A significant part of the reason for transfer pricing comes from legal loopholes and tax policies. The legal system is not yet complete, lacks transparency mechanisms and does not provide sufficient independent comparison data, allowing businesses to take advantage of it to adjust prices.
For example: Previously, some businesses took advantage of the lack of clear regulations on methods for determining transfer pricing or gaps in documents and records to record profits in places with low tax rates.
Technical and accounting reasons
Technical and accounting factors are also important causes of transfer pricing. Lack of documentation to support transfer pricing, choosing the wrong valuation method, or recording inappropriate costs all lead to price adjustments that do not accurately reflect market prices.
For example: Enterprises applying the cost plus method that is not suitable for the type of transaction, or failing to compare comparable data from the independent market, will lead to the risk of being assessed by tax authorities as transfer pricing behavior..
Causes of business ethics
Finally, business ethics cannot be ignored. Some businesses deliberately take advantage of legal loopholes, considering tax risks as “acceptable costs”. Lack of compliance culture, not focusing on financial transparency and responsibility to the state budget are direct reasons why transfer pricing still exists, despite increasingly strict legal regulations.
Understanding the causes of transfer pricing not only helps explain why this behavior occurs, but also serves as a basis for assessing the negative impacts it brings. When businesses adjust transaction prices to optimize profits or take advantage of legal loopholes, these behaviors will directly affect budget revenue, create unfair competition and potentially pose risks of tax collection. Therefore, analyzing the consequences of transfer pricing behavior is to help businesses and management agencies identify risks and come up with appropriate solutions.
Consequences of transfer pricing behavior
Identifying the causes of transfer pricing is just the first step; it is important to understand the consequences of transfer pricing so that businesses and management agencies can assess the risks and take appropriate measures. Typical consequences include:
Loss of state budget revenue
When businesses adjust transaction prices between related parties to transfer profits to countries or territories with lower tax rates, the state budget suffers significant revenue losses. As a result, financial resources for socio-economic development programs, infrastructure and public services are directly affected.
For example: An FDI company records profits mainly at its overseas subsidiaries, Vietnam will lose a significant amount of corporate income tax compared to the actual revenue generated domestically.
Unhealthy competitive environment
Enterprises that fully comply with their tax obligations incur higher costs than those that implement transfer pricing. This leads to an unfair competitive environment, making it difficult for compliant enterprises to maintain their market advantage, especially in industries with low profit margins and high competitive pressure.
Risk of collection and penalties
Transfer pricing can lead to serious legal risks if it does not comply with tax regulations. Enterprises may be asked to explain the reasonableness of related-party transactions, and if there is no complete supporting documentation, they may be subject to administrative sanctions or tax arrears. Lack of transparency in transfer pricing reporting can also cause enterprises to be assessed as having signs of tax evasion, affecting their reputation and business operations.
Financial risks and corporate reputation
Failure to strictly control transfer pricing behavior can lead to unreasonable expenses, affecting the profits and cash flow of the business. In addition, if detected, the business may face tax inspections, heavy tax adjustments and unnecessary fines. This not only affects finances but also reduces the confidence of partners, investors and customers, damaging the reputation and brand of the business.
Solutions to limit transfer pricing behavior
Understanding the causes of transfer pricing is the foundation for businesses to build an effective risk management strategy. From understanding the causes, businesses can apply the following solutions:
Mastering tax laws and policies
Enterprises need to update and thoroughly understand the regulations on deductible expenses, tax incentives, fixed asset depreciation policies, as well as the conditions for an expense to be validly recorded. Understanding the law helps enterprises proactively control risks arising from transfer pricing, optimize costs within the legal framework and avoid violating tax regulations.
Building a transparent affiliate transaction profile
One of the main reasons why businesses are at risk of transfer pricing is that their transaction records are incomplete or lack transparency. Therefore, businesses need to prepare detailed transaction records that comply with international standards and reflect the actual value. Clear records help businesses minimize the risk of being charged or fined by tax authorities, and at the same time enhance their reputation during inspections and audits.
Applying the market price principle
To limit risks, businesses must ensure that transaction prices between related parties are equivalent to market prices. This directly addresses one of the common causes of transfer pricing, ensuring that profits are allocated appropriately between companies in the group, while reducing the risk of violating tax laws.
Internal audit and periodic risk assessment
Enterprises need to conduct regular internal audits to detect early signs of unusual or unreasonable transactions. This helps to promptly handle issues related to transfer pricing causes, avoid tax arrears and minimize administrative fines.
Reference tax consulting services career
Even if a business has a team of highly skilled accountants, there are still complex tax aspects that only experienced professionals can identify and handle accurately. Consulting a reputable tax consulting service is an effective solution for businesses to identify potential transfer pricing causes, limit legal risks and build appropriate strategies.
There are some methods that can help businesses reduce taxes in the short term, but in the long term, these methods pose serious legal risks. On the contrary, if businesses apply legal tax optimization strategies, strictly manage taxes and fully comply with transfer pricing regulations in Vietnam, they can still significantly reduce their tax obligations without facing the risk of collection or penalties.
Conclude
The cause of transfer pricing often comes from businesses seeking to maximize global profits by adjusting transaction prices between related parties to transfer profits from high-tax areas to low-tax areas. Instead of finding ways to circumvent the law or passively dealing with tax inspections due to suspected transfer pricing causes, businesses should proactively grasp the rules of the game, be transparent in each transaction and intelligently apply legal regulations on transfer pricing. This will help businesses turn tax compliance into a competitive advantage. When taxes are no longer a concern, businesses can truly focus on core values - business development and building a reputable brand in the market.
If your business is still wondering about transfer pricing activities and the reasons for transfer pricing, do not hesitate to contact MAN – Master Accountant Network for advice and support in preparing declarations and transfer pricing documents. With a team of experienced and solid expertise, let MAN – Master Accountant Network accompany your business to solve all problems quickly and effectively.
Contact information MAN – Master Accountant Network
- Address: No. 19A, Street 43, Tan Thuan Ward, Ho Chi Minh City
- Mobile / Zalo: 0903 428 622 (Ms. Ngan)
- E-mail: man@man.net.vn
Editorial Board: MAN – Master Accountant Network